Showing posts with label Republican Party. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Republican Party. Show all posts

Thursday, November 29, 2007

“The Real Rudy” – David Brooks 11/23/07

I watched a brief portion of the Republican YouTube debate on CNN last night. The issue of immigration came up (I understand it continued to do so throughout) and I was reminded of this David Brooks editorial from last week. The editorial focuses on Rudy G., and his apparent flip-flop from vigilant pro-immigrant NYC mayor to xenophobic authoritarian candidate. This transition has really manifested itself mostly in the past year, and to any serious follower of politics appears to be rooted in pandering to the perceived GOP base. Brooks selects numerous quotes from Giuliani’s past to highlight this change.

I am normally not a big fan of “gotcha” politics or journalism, but I am enthralled by the amount of backpedaling going on from several GOP candidates on the issue of immigration. Romney and Giuliani are the leaders in this reversal in direction from their earlier executive actions to the new “get’em out” mentality.

“At the moment, Giuliani and fellow moderate Mitt Romney are attacking each other for being insufficiently Tancredo-esque. They are not renouncing the policies they championed as city and state officials, but the emphasis as they run for federal office is all in the other direction. In effect, they are competing to drive away Hispanic votes and make the party unelectable in New Mexico, Arizona, Colorado, Nevada, Florida and the nation at large.”

I do believe that this ideological stance on an issue so personal to so many citizens is not in the long-term best interest of the GOP or the nation as a whole. The growing Hispanic population is an important part of America and to treat them as the “unwanted other” is to give way to xenophobic fear mongering at its worst. I do not proclaim to know the answer to the immigration issues that are facing America today, but I am confident that the vitriol being put into the “political debate” by the GOP candidates does not have a place in true political discourse. I should point out that I thought Huckabee and McCain were much more political in their responses that I heard on this issue. I never thought I would say that Huckabee seems more desirable and moderate at this point than Romney or Giuliani...

Tuesday, November 13, 2007

“Health Care Excuses” – Krugman 11/9/07

Last Friday (before taking a sick day Monday?), Mr. Krugman offered a quick rebuttal to four of the favorite talking points for apologists of the current American health care industry. Krugman does a good job of deconstructing these four arguments into recognizable one-liners that reverberate through contemporary American culture:

1. No Insurance, No Problem
2. It’s the Cheeseburgers
3. 2007 is better than 1950
4. Socialized Medicine! Socialized Medicine

Point #1 is a true statement, if by health care you mean emergency care at a hospital. It is not true, however, if you are attempting to seek preventive care from most clinics or if you are seeking mental health treatment. This isn’t to say you can’t get this care without insurance, but the vast majority of Americans without insurance (the working poor) cannot afford it. Krugman highlights some of the other flaws with this logic:

We’re told, for example, that there really aren’t that many uninsured American citizens, because some of the uninsured are illegal immigrants, while some of the rest are actually entitled to Medicaid. This misses the point that the 47 million people in this country without insurance are an ever-changing group, so that the experience of being without insurance extends to a much broader group — in fact, more than one in every three people in America under the age of 65 was uninsured at some point in 2006 or 2007.

The “they are all illegal immigrants” and the “they might be coverable by Medicaid” are both arguments used to prop up a failing national health care policy. Are some of the 47 million uninsured in this country illegal? Probably so. Are others eligible for Medicaid? Almost undoubtedly. Do these two groups sum to 47 million? Definitely not. I know I spent a portion of 2006 uninsured, as I’m sure many professionals in between jobs or returning to school can attest – there are a lot of uninsured Americans out there who have no viable method of securing health care coverage.

Point #2 illustrates the argument that our health care costs are higher because we take on a heightened amount of risky behavior and lifestyle choices. We eat too much and don’t exercise; We drive to fast; and We saturate our lives with stress. This sounds like a great reason for an expensive health care system, but a McKinsey Global Institute report begs to differ. The report finds Americans are not significantly sicker than other countries studied.

As to #3, well to be as kind as I can be --- that is just stupid. Of course we have improved health care immensely over the last half a century, but we’ve have an even more amazing increase in knowledge and ability regarding computers and that has led to more access and lower costs.

Point #4 is the final corner of retreat for at least a quarter of all American politicians on any issue – “Program X is socialist, commie, pinko, over-regulated, inefficient, non-market based, abandons individual responsibility, and is bad for the economy.” These politicians will continue to spew this vitriol about these programs, until you bring up Medicare. Then they talk about how it’s such a wonderful program for our elderly population.

We have both supply and demand issues in America’s health care policy, but maybe it is time to start considering solutions instead of continuously giving heed to reactionary politicos and pundits who haven’t been without health care in at least twenty years (if ever). America already pays for premium health care, isn’t it time we give access to it to all Americans?

Wednesday, November 7, 2007

“Wobbled by Wealth?” – Krugman 11/5/07

Are the Democrats becoming corrupted by the influx of cash from wealthy supporters? This question is becoming more pertinent in the Democratic Party, as for the first time in recent history; the Democrats have raised more cash than the GOP from the business world. Are the Democratic officials selling out their progressive base by accepting the largesse of corporate America, or are they taking advantage of a political opportunity to broaden the power base?

The answer to this question will likely not come until sometime after 1/20/09, when a new president (likely Dem) will be able to develop an agenda for the nation. Will this agenda feature a more equitable tax structure with fewer loopholes and deductions for the rich? Will health insurance reform see the light of day? Will insurance reform to ensure that long-term policyholders aren’t dropped without cause become law? Or will hedge fund managers call on Mr. Schumer, drug companies on Hilary, and insurance on Mr. Dodd? Though this sounds a bit doomsdayish, the biggest concern I have is that progressives will fail to support the Democratic Party because they view it as the same as the GOP. Krugman hit the nail on the head on this point:

“O.K., some perspective. I sometimes hear people say that there’s no difference between Democrats and Republicans; that’s foolish. Look at the fight over children’s health insurance, and you can see how different the parties’ philosophies and priorities really are. All of the leading Democratic candidates are offering strongly progressive policy proposals; the Republicans are, if anything, running to the right of the Bush administration.

Perspective is key here, and I am not convinced that the Democratic presidential hopefuls are completely devoid of progressive principles. They have shown a willingness to at least espouse progressive ideals on the campaign trail. I am, like Krugman however, worried.

I have hope that opening the doors to business will generate immense electoral gains, arguably solidifying a governing coalition that can make a positive globalization effect for America into the future. I also have my concerns - Business is a bit of a serial monogamist, where nothing is forever. If the Democrats pursue this path of working closely with business, they may just cut some of the power out from under themselves were they to pursue a progressive agenda viewed as too extreme by the business community. Conversely, if they pursue an overly business friendly agenda, the possibility of losing unions, labor, and progressives is also real. I don’t believe in entrenched party lines, as they tend to make compromises more and more difficult as absolutes are embedded in party platforms. I do, however, find some cause for concern when the party that is stopping big boy hedge fund managers (all 150 of them) from being equitably taxed on their sizable income is the same party that for years has claimed to represent all the little guys out there.

Friday, October 19, 2007

“Death of the Machine” – Krugman – 10/19/07

Friday's NYT has Krugman discussing corporate campaign financing via K Street.The ability of the Republican Party to raise significantly more funds, especially from the business community, has been considered a given over the last few election cycles. The methods of Rove and elected Republicans, such as Santorum, to garner a permanent majority were predicated on the ability to grossly outspend opponents in elections. The current election cycle is strongly challenging this given, as Democrats are receiving more funds from each of the top ten industries in America. The question at the core of this issue is why is corporate America abandoning the GOP at this rate? The easy answer is political calculus. This argument holds that businesses know how to read the signs of an impending bomb of an election for the GOP in 2008. With 22 of the 34 contested Senate seats held by Republicans, a wave of GOP retirements in the House, and a lackluster presidential field the corporate world is quite simply hedging on the likelihood of a unified Democratic government for the first time since 1993. This calculus, along with the business community getting tired of seemingly being held hostage by the Republican Party, are two of the likely reasons for the funding shift.

Another possible cause of the growing gulf between business and the GOP is the lack of competency by the current administration. Though it is hard to argue that Bush has been unfriendly to business, his actions and policies have not exactly been the most conducive to growth and stability in the national and world economy. Disruption, volatility, and incoherent policies are bad for business, and the current administration has had no shortage of any of the three.

I would add two additional reasons for this growing disaffection between GOP and business. The first is that as the GOP maintains its intimate relationship with social conservative organizations and groups, the business community is forced to recognize that the GOP isn’t always with them – but occasionally must pander to the vote base. A singular example of this issue is the public financing of research facilities for stem cells – here in Madison the business community is very receptive to the idea, while the religious organizations are vehemently opposed. The final reason, and most disturbing, that I can come up with regards to business money flowing to the Dems instead of the GOP, is that the Democratic National Committee and the presidential candidates are viewed as in the pocket of big business.

Krugman, I think, would disagree with this last point being intentional, but he recognizes it as a real possibility:

“Many progressives, myself included, hope that the next president will be another F.D.R. But we worry that he or she will turn out to be another Grover Cleveland instead – better-intentioned and much more competent than the current occupant of the White House, but too dependent on lobbyists’ money to seriously confront the excesses of our new Gilded Age.”

The idea that a Democrat may be well intentioned, but unable to make some necessary politically bold moves seems more likely when the influx of corporate dollars is noted. The business community is often inherently conservative in nature – along with being enemies of volatility and incoherent policies; they also fight against change and any policy that is assumed to be harmful to the bottom line. I am, like Krugman, very concerned that we have established such a low baseline over the past seven years for leadership, that the progressives in America will rally behind a candidate that is primarily financed by some of the very industries (pharmaceuticals and insurance) that are most impeding necessary social changes.

Wednesday, October 17, 2007

“Sliming Graeme Frost” – Krugman – 10/12/07

Last Friday, Paul Krugman took issue with the lambasting of Graeme Frost at the hands of the right-wing media machine. It is frustrating for me to watch our political discourse continually fall to this level. I loathe the carelessness in the media of presenting information and the corresponding laxity with which the populace consumes it. Though I am unwilling to exclusively condemn one side of the political spectrum, it does seem that this program of personal attacks by innuendo and lies is utilized entirely too often by the “mainstream” conservative pundits. Krugman points out that these are not “fringe elements” within the right wing media, but folks like Limbaugh and Malkin who are often cited and greatly respected (within their portion of the spectrum) sources of political information.
Believe it or not, I think America needs these folks on the right to stir the political pot with their perspective. The unfortunate reality is that this role of biased (not in a bad way) media outlets is being, along with many other aspects of our discourse, continually polarized where the other side cannot be given quarter at any time. This mentality is, in and of itself, not political – but a zero-sum war game where by one side always wins and the other loses. This is to me one of the biggest failures of a portion of the political spectrum that claims to be so pro-business. The failure to recognize a basic premise of economics - that win-win outcomes are where the most value is added – informs me that there is little interest in making America better in aggregate. The point is to make America better for a certain constituency.

“Politics aside, the Graeme Frost case demonstrates the true depth of the health care crisis: every other advanced country has universal health insurance, but in America, insurance is now out of reach for many hard-working families, even if they have incomes that some might call middle class... ultimately, this isn’t about the Frost parents. It’s about Graeme Frost and his sister. I don’t know about you, but I think American children who need medical care should get it, period. Even if you think adults have made bad choices – a baseless smear in the case of the Frosts, but put that on one side – only a truly vicious political movement would respond by punishing their injured children.”

Thank you Mr. Krugman. This is not as much of a political issue as it is an ethical one. I, along with many others, have lived through a childhood of no health insurance coverage. Children in these positions are exposed to countless health issues that if treated or addressed at an early age may not have a serious impact on their lives, but left untreated we put these kids at a health disadvantage as they enter adulthood. I guess our land of equal opportunity doesn’t apply to health, or education, or dynastic wealth....